Doves On Distant Oaks
Let the peace of Christ rule in your hearts, since as members of one body you were called to peace. And be thankful. Let the message of Christ dwell among you richly as you teach and admonish one another with all wisdom through psalms, hymns, and songs from the Spirit, singing to God with gratitude in your hearts. And whatever you do, whether in word or deed, do it all in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him. – Colossians 3:15-17
E-mail: ehwharton@Writing.com
"TABLE OF CONTENTS"
"KEYWORDS"
Whats the meaning behind 'Doves on Distant Oaks?' ▼
While reading Psalm 56, which contains my wife's favorite verse, I was struck by the instruction at the beginning:
For the director of music. To the tune of “A Dove on Distant Oaks."
–Preface to Psalm 56
I've worked my entire life as a forester and spent many days walking through woodlands under the sheltering arms of majestic oaks. It was during those times I recognized my insignificance and felt a great loneliness, contained as we are inside these bag of bones and skin with a spirit that longs to be free and soar with God.
Psalm 56 was written by King David (before he was king) and I imagine it must have been how David felt as he was being hunted through the mountains by King Saul. He was hungry, tired, and alone. The melody, A Dove on Distant Oaks, has been lost to history, but it was probably familiar to David. He may have wished he could have sprouted wings, flown away, and joined that dove in song, much as we will one day break free of the chains of this world and sing praises directly to our Holy God.
So this is just me, listening to the song of doves on distant oaks, anticipating the day I will fly away to sing my praises before God.
What version of the Bible is used? ▼
According to Pastor Kenneth Collins (2010) there are three bibles you'd expect to find in mainline churches. He states these include The King James Version (KJV), the "authorized" version that remains the preferred bible; The New American Standard Bible (NASB) used in independent churches that rely heavily on bible study during worship; and the modern English Version, called the Good News Translation (GNT), that’s used with moderate to liberal theological, social, and political thought.
In some churches, the only acceptable version is The King James Version, particularly for older church goers. However, It’s almost incomprehensible to anyone not at ease reading it. For the new Christian, it’s perplexing. The New American Standard Bible tried to produce an accurate translation that read more easily. It’s accurate and excellent for serious study. The Good News Translation was written so that people who didn’t go to church could understand it. It reads like a novel, particularly that of Old Testament history.
Many authors use several versions, probably to present a biblical verse which supports their opinion within the context of their discourse. I prefer to use a single version because consistency is far more valuable, in my opinion, than trying to make the Bible say what you want it it say. Regardless, the version used has to be done with painstaking care that balances style, readability, and accuracy.
With that in mind, I chose to use the New King James version (NKJV) because I have always loved the stylistic beauty of the King James version which the New King James version maintains. I recognize the weakness of the original version—of not having had access to more recent research. That was all resolved by the New King James version completed in 1982 after seven years of scholarly research. It remains true to the style of the King James, with a few changes to the more archaic phrases, but has the added benefit of more recent research.
I know that this selection my disturb some people, particularly those who think the "old" KJV to be the only Bible, but consider the comparison of it with the King James version using one of my favorite verses of Jeremiah 29:11. Below is that verse in different versions listed by original date of publication.
For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, saith the LORD, thoughts of peace, and not of evil, to give you an expected end.
King James Version, KJV, first published in 1611
Four revisions (latest 1769—mostly fonts, typos, spelling, and punctuation). Considered the only “authorized" bible, which contains some beautiful imagery.
For I have known the thoughts that I am thinking towards you—an affirmation of Jehovah; thoughts of peace, and not of evil, to give to you posterity and hope.
Young's Literal Translation, YLT, first published in 1862
Two revisions (latest 1898). Though difficult to read, this literal translation conforms to the actual grammar and verb tenses of the original Greek and Hebrew.
For I know the plans that I have for you, declares the Lord, ‘plans for welfare and not for calamity to give you a future and a hope.
New American Standard Bible, NASB, full Bible first published in 1971
Five revisions (latest 1995—vocabulary, grammar, and sentence structure).
A contemporary English Bible maintaining word-for-word translation with improved reliability while maintaining fidelity to original languages and latest finds.
I alone know the plans I have for you, plans to bring you prosperity and not disaster, plans to bring about the future you hope for.
Good News Translation, GNT, full Bible first published in 1976
One revision (1992—incorporates inclusive language). A clear modern translation whose focus on ease of understanding sometimes sacrifices poetry for clarity.
For I know the plans I have for you, declares the LORD, plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future.
New International Version, NIV, first published in 1978
Two revisions (latest 2011—dropping gender specific language). A middle of the road version that expresses the scriptures in broadly understood modern English.
For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, says the Lord, thoughts of peace and not of evil, to give you a future and a hope.
New King James Version, NKJV, full Bible first published 1982
No revisions. Retains the stylistic beauty and textual basis of the original King James updated to modern language and includes most recent research.
I know what I’m doing. I have it all planned out—plans to take care of you, not abandon you, plans to give you the future you hope for.
The Message, MSG, first published in 1993
Two revisions (latest 2008). A reading Bible that facilitates easy and enjoyable reading and which tries to recapture the Bible in the words we use today.
For I know the plans I have for you, says the LORD. They are plans for good and not for disaster, to give you a future and a hope.
New Living Translation, NLT, first published in 1996
Two revisions (latest 2007). A thought-by-thought translation less accurate but easier understood on the presumption that more hear the Bible read aloud than study it.
I've included Young's Literal Translation because it's wise to compare scriptural passages from other versions with it. Compiled by Robert Young in 1862, it renders the syntax of the wording as close as possible to the original Greek and Hebrew. Young was attempting to make sure that translations not forget, as they often do, that punctuation and grammar can change meanings. In the preface to the second edition, he wrote:
… It is clear that verbal inspiration is as much overlooked as if it had no existence. The Word of God is made void by the traditions of men.
This translation may suffer from being published before some recent research was available (particularly in terms of word definitions), but it can lead to greater understanding when comparing the arrangements of words and phrases and verb tenses.
An analysis of the differences of this verse can be broken down into three phrases: 1) an acknowledgment of God's contemplation, 2) God's exact thinking, and 3) the consequences.
God's contemplation
The KJV, YLT, and NKJV indicate that God is thinking about us. All other versions specify what those thoughts are, that of His plans for us. This does not mean the word "thoughts" is wrong. It's the case of all thumbs are fingers, but not all fingers are thumbs. Plans are thoughts, but thoughts are not necessarily plans. So which is it? Thoughts in general or the more specific plans ... and does it really matter? In all translations, we know God had not abandoned His people.
God's exact thinking
Once again the KJV, YLT, and NKJV are consistent in their use of "peace and not evil." The others, however, are quite dissimilar.
NASB — welfare and not calamity
GNT — prosperity and not disaster
NIV — to prosper you and not to harm you
MSG — to take care of you, not to abandon you
NLT — for good and not for disaster
My take would be that the translations that seeks to make the text more readable are casting about, trying to find an appropriate word in modern English that approximates "peace and not evil." That, rather than more precise words from updated textual research. Otherwise, the more modern versions would all have the same words. This is where these modern "readable" translations fall apart, because who is to say what is the correct modern word to use in that context. The word "prosperity" is a big leap from "good" and "disaster" a big leap from "abandonment."
The consequences
KJV — an expected end
YLT — posterity and hope
NASB — future and a hope
NKJV — future and a hope
NLT — future and a hope
NIV — hope and a future
GNT — the future you hope for
MSG — the future you hope for
Here we begin to see a difference that may actually be a result of more recent research into linguistics resulting in a more accurate translation. The "expected end" of the KJV (which is quite vague) became "posterity and hope" by the time of the YLT translation in 1862. Posterity relates to future generations, so by then the translators were getting close to the actual meaning. By modern times that was translated simply as "a future."
The only disturbing thing here is that the GNT and MSG have altered "a future and a hope" into "the future you hope for," which produces a vastly different understanding. In their attempt to make the text more readable, they have altered the meaning … in my opinion.
Why the NIV felt the need to flip the two is beyond my abilities to understand.
It seems that each version has its own particular use. For personal Bible study, I lean toward the NASB with a pinch of YLT thrown in to promote comprehension. For reading to children our reading aloud to assemblies of people, I lean toward the NLT, GNT, or MSG. For a devotional such as this, where style and readability with accuracy is needed, I've leaned toward the NKJV.
I don't want to slight the NIV, which, though wildly popular, suffers from trying to be a compromise version between modern language and textual accuracy—incorporating the weaknesses of both. I also don't mean to slight the KJV which, in some ways, is still my favorite version because I grew up on it. I just feel that the most recent research in archaeology, linguistics, and textual studies needs to be acknowledged.
Source:
Collins, Rev. Kenneth in www.kencollins.com/bible-t2.htm#nasb
Like Roman SoldiersMay 2, 2024 at 4:30pm Much has been written about the armor that the apostle Paul suggests we wear to face our enemy, the spiritual Evil ones {Ephesians 6:14-18}. Paul uses the metaphor of a Roman soldier because, of course, that's what a soldier wore during the times in which he lived. However, we can compare it to the modern soldier as well.
All soldiers wear combat gear and equipment depending on their need. Some carry the barest of essentials, designed to move quickly and strike quietly. Others are we... [ Read more] Bid Me ComeApril 30, 2024 at 2:03pm Many years ago, I saw a Christian rock band in concert. The band has since split up because the lead singer decided there was missionary work he felt God was calling him to do. Before he left, though they played wonderful music. They played some softer ballads, but the bulk of their music got the audience jumping with loud rock songs. That's not really my style, through I appreciate the niche they filled by appealing to younger people. I'll raise my hands and sing along … but ju... [ Read more] Being Single-mindedApril 19, 2024 at 7:37pm It's not often I turn to the secular world for insight, but every now and then I find justification for God's will in the writing of mankind. In terms of purity of heart, something that's always on my mind, one of the finest discussions was written by Søren Kierkegaard in Purity of Heart is to Will One Thing: Spiritual Preparation for the Office of Confession . What he suggested was that the heart cannot be divided—that a pure heart was one that set its will on only one thing... [ Read more] The Divinity of ChristApril 19, 2024 at 7:44pm In Matthew 14:22-33, we find another famous story, the story of Jesus walking on water. There are so many lessons we can learn from this event in the life of Jesus. There's constantly looking toward Jesus in times of trouble, obeying Jesus when He commands, taking the first step in faith, unleashing the power of faith, faltering with fear will sink you, and knowing Jesus will always come when you call out in distress.
I'm sure there are others, because this story contains a... [ Read more] Splendor in the GrassApril 30, 2024 at 7:20pm The Parable of the farmer sowing seeds is a well-known parable taught by Jesus Christ (Matthew 13:1-23, Mark 4:1-20, Luke 8:4-15). Its meaning is clear because Jesus took the time to explain it to his apostles. There is, however, a verse in all three Gospels that is often forgotten in favor of the more powerful meaning that Jesus was teaching. Still, it is important to the Christian walk.
It has to do with yield from seeds planted on good soil (Matthew 13:8):
But others fell on the g... [ Read more] The Good ShepherdApril 19, 2024 at 7:55pm The 23rd Psalm is perhaps one of the most well known Psalms, certainly the most quoted from the Old Testament. The author, King David, presents a vivid picture of how God takes care of those who love Him.
Often we hear the same analogy repeated throughout the New Testament by Jesus in his teachings. In them, Jesus becomes the good shepherd watching over His flock, searching out those who have left the fold, and responding to their needs. Certainly, followers of Christ need guidance and pro... [ Read more] Calling Down FireApril 19, 2024 at 7:57pm I wonder what it must have been like to be rebuked by Jesus? He did so at times to his disciples and I don't think it was a simple, "Now, now, boys. You know that's not right." If Jesus rebuked them like he rebuked the Pharisees, they probably felt about as small as a baby ant. Funny how one simple word like "rebuke" can conjure up such powerful imagery.
Two disciples, James and John, in particular had a propensity for getting into trouble. Often we think of Jo... [ Read more] The Good, Bad, and Ugly of PrideApril 30, 2024 at 7:25pm We often think the first sin was committed by Adam and Eve in the Garden, which was disobedience, coupled with their failure to ask forgiveness. But their sin was strictly how sin entered the world. There was a sin that preceded them—the real first sin. It was the sin of pride by Lucifer when he felt he was equal to God.
Perhaps it was pride and not disobedience that Adam and Eve first committed as well. If we consider that Satan convinced Eve that "she would not die" by eatin... [ Read more] The Sacrificial LifeApril 30, 2024 at 7:34pm As followers of Christ, we are called to forfeit our self-centered desires in favor of serving others. This is called the sacrificial life, but what does that really mean? How much, and when, are we supposed to sacrifice? Are we to be like the rich young ruler that told Jesus he had led an exemplary life, and asked what more he needed to do.
Jesus said to him, “If you want to be perfect, go, sell what you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; and come, follow... [ Read more] You Gotta Have FaithApril 30, 2024 at 8:29pm What is faith? The dictionary definition of faith would be the complete trust in someone or something based on expectation rather than proof. The writer of the Book of Hebrews, however, states that faith is complete trust in someone as proof of expectation: "Now faith is the certainty of things hoped for, a proof of things not seen" (Hebrews 11:1). In other words, our faith is based on a trust that knows, beyond any doubt, that God will act according to His promises.
We can have fa... [ Read more] Catch a WaveApril 20, 2024 at 3:49pm One of the joys of living in the Philadelphia PA region for a number of years was traveling into the city to watch Phillies baseball games with my family. This was at the old Veterans Stadium that has since been torn down. Other than a number of timely home runs and stunning fielding plays, made by some memorable players like Schmidt and Carlton, one of my favorite memories was being part of the first ever Veterans Stadium wave.
You don't see much of them these days, but back "in th... [ Read more] The "Jason Bourne" of the BibleApril 30, 2024 at 8:34pm I love studying the interesting array of real-life people in the Bible, especially the obscure ones. The Bible is full of such characters, some good and some bad. At times we get so caught up in the famous people that we forget that they all, no matter how little-known, have something to teach us. And in terms of the followers of Jesus, the one that I find most interesting is Simon the Zealot. He is the most obscure of all of the apostles and has been called "The Mystery Man" of the ap... [ Read more] The Fear of Righteous JudgmentApril 30, 2024 at 8:38pm When I worked in Washington State, I took a trip to see a geologic formation called the Dry Falls. Today, they are just 400-foot cliffs in the scab-lands of central Washington, but twenty thousand years ago, a giant waterfall five times the width of Niagara Falls spilled over them. Ice sheets from melting glaciers that had dammed rivers suddenly broke free and catastrophic flooding caused parts of Idaho, Washington, and Oregon to be under hundreds of feet of water in just a few days. The 65-mi... [ Read more] A Flu Shot for the SoulApril 30, 2024 at 8:39pm When I was younger, I owned a motorcycle. It was a cheap mode of transportation for a poor college student, even though everyone warned me I was driving a two-wheeled coffin. For safety, I always wore a helmet and kept my headlight on (this was before mandatory helmets). One day, that might have been the difference between life and death.
I was coming home from classes, driving down a narrow street and approached an intersection. Though I had the right-of-way, a car suddenly appeared ou... [ Read more] Is it Sympathy or EmpathyApril 30, 2024 at 8:40pm We all try to avoid going to the hospital, but one time I got so sick I had to go for an extended stay. When they finally released me, I was so happy to be leaving that I could think of little else. Most of us are like that—so glad to be headed home from the hospital that our focus is only on ourselves. But as we were leaving, my wife suggested we stop and pray for those who weren't headed home, who remained in sickness. In the midst of our happiness, we stopped and took their sadness on... [ Read more] Planting TurnipsApril 30, 2024 at 8:41pm As a history enthusiast, I recall a story I once read about Hannibal's invasion of Italy during the Punic Wars. He had surrounded a city called Casilinum and refused to offer any terms of surrender for them. Since a portion of their food supply grew outside the city walls, Hannibal plowed up all the vegetable and other herbage plants that grew there—a sort-of scorched earth policy.
As the wait to starve them out drug on, one day he noticed women coming outside the walls and beginnin... [ Read more] Are We Not All Beggars?May 2, 2024 at 4:15pm I tend to jump around from one version to another when I study passages from the Bible. That's because I understand the difficulties of translating from archaic texts. Sometimes it's difficult to translate a Hebrew or Greek word or phrase exactly into English—there may be no word that fits it. So, I like to see how different translations express it.
In doing so, I sometimes come upon words that jump out at me and touch me in a special way. One of those words is "lovingkindness... [ Read more] Show, Don't TellApril 30, 2024 at 8:43pm When I was learning my profession at a university, I was fortunate to have been educated under some prominent professors in my field of study. They were not so well-known that the general public would have heard of them, but in their professions, they were giants. Often, years later when I would make a statement, someone would say, "You must have studied under so-and-so, you sound just like them." I never took that as an affront or insult. Rather, I took it as an acknowledgment of the... [ Read more] The Philosophy of LinusApril 30, 2024 at 8:44pm At one point in Jesus' ministry, the Pharisees came before him and challenged Him with questions, hoping to trip Him up. One pressed Him on which of the commandments was the greatest, testing not so much his knowledge, but his judgment. Jesus showed these religious leaders that the entire Law and the writings of the prophets could be summed up in a few simple sentences:
Then one of them, a lawyer, asked Him a question, testing Him, and saying, "Teacher, which is the great comman... [ Read more] TetelestaiApril 30, 2024 at 11:43pm I often hear people talk, or write, about the mission of Jesus. They say that Jesus was a good teacher, may have even performed miracles and healed people; He’s even someone they look up to and want to emulate. But … thats all. They don’t believe he had any other mission to fulfill during his 33-odd years while alive.
There is a specific word that Jesus spoke from the cross that refutes this belief. That word is tetelestai . It's often translated as "it is finished" an... [ Read more] The Walk of LifeApril 30, 2024 at 11:45pm Do you, or did you ever, have a burden to bear in your life? During the last years of her life, my ailing mother was left without anyone to help her. My father had died many years before, at which point my mother moved in to live with her sister. When my aunt died, my mother was left with no one.
It was at that point my wife and I built an in-law suite onto our house. We moved my mother in to live with us and my wife quit her job to work full time caring for her. It was a selfless act ... [ Read more] Muscles of FaithApril 30, 2024 at 11:53pm Most biblical scholars agree that Job is the oldest book in the Bible, predating the first five books of the Old Testament written by Moses. They only argue about how old it is, which many think was slightly before the time of Abraham. As such, it's the earliest written record of God's relationship with man.
Just as important, it's the earliest written record of God's relationship with Satan. We see in the book of Job that the Satan is restricted by God with regard to how ... [ Read more] Like a ChildMay 1, 2024 at 9:12am I was thinking today about how to strengthen my relationship with God. What was one act of obedience I can do that might help? There are lots of choices in the Bible, but I kept coming back to one thing.
In a word, humility.
I have been on a quest lately to understand what true humility is and how to grow closer to God through it. Certainly, the Bible is full of verses on the need to be humble, and our Lord and Savior showed what true humility is by washing the feet of his disciples. ... [ Read more] SignpostsMay 1, 2024 at 4:43pm When Christ walked the earth, He performed many miracles. Yet, they were not the reason He stepped down from heaven. He performed them because of his great sadness over the suffering of humanity, but more importantly as signposts. Like any signpost, their only value lay in their function to guide the traveler to some destination. The destination was, of course, the cross.
That means anything that has happened in our lives that point to Christ as our savior, who died on the cross for u... [ Read more] The Cross or the ThroneApril 25, 2024 at 7:36pm At one point in the Apostle Paul’s ministry, he decided to send his loyal follower, Timothy, to the church at Philippi. He wanted to more fully understand their situation and find out how they were doing.
Timothy had a Greek father and a Jewish mother, and probably responded to the Gospel during Paul’s first missionary journey. He joined Paul on a later missionary journey while probably still in his late teens or early twenties. Evidently, he had endeared himself to Paul, who addres... [ Read more] |
© Copyright 2024 Eric Wharton (UN: ehwharton at Writing.Com). All rights reserved. Eric Wharton has granted InkSpot.Com, its affiliates and its syndicates non-exclusive rights to display this work.
|